I've not picked up the book yet, but I used to read the New Teen Titans (an 80''s comic book) back in the day. To read the reviews that are posted, you'd think that fanboys didn't like, y'know, hot women, action sequences, or explosions. I guess that changed since I was a li'l fangirl and hung out w/ the fan boys in the comic shops.
I read one review that said that they were shocked that a teenaged girl (Raven) would (gasp) show part of her thong underwear in public...so what part of 1995 are they rejecting? I suspect that the negative reviews are more about the team behind the book than the actual book itself. I hope that these reviewers stop taking "Titans #1" so friggen seriously.